Editorial Record: Submitted August 5, 2024. Revised and accepted December 4, 2025.
Author
Virginia Harrison Assistant Professor Clemson University South Carolina, USA Email: vsharri@g.clemson.edu
ABSTRACT
This class-tested GIFT demonstrates the value of service-learning in an academic master’s degree quantitative methods course. Students in small groups developed a theory-driven research project to help a local nonprofit understand donation motivations among the undergraduate student body. The assignment required them to build public relations and communications theory while developing meaningful takeaways for the partner nonprofit. Students reported feeling less intimidated by quantitative methods, learning principles of scholarly research, and feeling good about helping their community. The nonprofit partner also said they valued the data collected by the students for their fundraising planning. The GIFT illustrates how a quantitative research assignment with a real-world application may serve a classroom of communication students who express different goals—either pursuing a Ph.D. or entering the profession—while benefiting town-gown relations.
Editorial Record: Original draft submitted to JPRE December 21, 2018. Revision submitted April 22, 2019. Manuscript accepted for publication May 24, 2019. First published online August 17, 2019.
Author
Christopher Jon McCollough, Columbus State University
Abstract
Scholarship on service learning demonstrates a variety of benefits to students, faculty, universities, and surrounding communities. While literature in public relations education offers strong examples of community benefits pertaining to civic engagement, community service promotion, and fulfillment of the needs of local governments and nonprofit organizations, scholarship is just beginning to address the potential long-term benefits for economic development. Literature in business and economics education offers some indication of the potential value of service learning to economic development in communities. This article offers an account of the use of service learning in a senior internship and two public relations courses as part of a collaborative project to promote a community partnership, a visionary arts venue, and the community that stands to benefit from its success. The article discusses the project development, execution of courses, and subsequent early indicators of economic impact.
Keywords: service learning, nonprofit, internship, community, economic impact
Visionary Public Relations Coursework: Leveraging Service Learning in Public Relations Courses to Spur Economic Development Through the Arts, Travel, and Tourism
Service learning is a common approach to teaching in the
public relations curriculum, particularly in capstone and management courses.
The benefits of service learning to students are clear: direct application of
practice, grounding theory and principles of best practice in the real world,
and a wide variety of essential skills in communication that employers now
prioritize in entry-level employees (Muturi, An, & Mwangi, 2013; Werder
& Strand, 2011). The value of service learning to communities is also a
growing, well-established body of literature within the context of public
relations (Rogers & Andrews, 2015), as well as across disciplines (Bringle
& Hatcher, 1996).
One key potential area of impact is on economic development within communities. A body of literature in business pedagogy demonstrates the value of using service-learning projects in the classroom of inner city (Desplaces, Steinberg, Coleman, & Kenworthy-U’Ren, 2006) and rural communities (Frazier, Niehm, & Stoel, 2012) in economic struggle, as well as for study abroad programs (Dato-On & Al-Charaak, 2013). That said, the current literature in public relations education (e.g., Fraustino, Pressgrove, & Colistra, 2019) is just beginning to examine the potential of service-learning projects to provide economic benefit to communities through nonprofit, public sector, or small business means. Public relations is a management function and plays a central role in organizational decision-making (J. E. Grunig & L. A. Grunig, 2008). As such, it stands that providing students with an opportunity to strengthen experience in economic development would have long-term benefits to the students and the organizations they represent.
This article offers a report on the conduct of a multi-term service-learning project across multiple public relations courses. The project’s initial aim was to promote a new arts and culture venue managed by the university, which grew to include recommendations and materials for helping the community adapt to a travel and tourism economy that supported those coming to visit the new venue, as well as promotion of the region surrounding the venue. The initial success of the first course projects provided students with the means to expand on the initial recommendations for the community to include execution of travel and tourism promotion to support local venues in a subsequent public relations management course, as well as an individual public relations internship focused on executing grant writing work and daily management of the community’s marketing and promotion of the venue. The net result was that the students’ work served to set up the subsequent efforts in economic development that continues to take place today. To gain insight on the economic impact of the community transition and potential value of student project work after the project’s completion, the author conducted an analysis of statewide and local economic data, along with open interviews with the local chamber of commerce to assess the impact of the project on the community. Early returns are positive, suggesting value of service-learning work to support community economic development initiatives.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Since Sigmon (1979) introduced the term service-learning, the pedagogical
practice has been defined by what students do to better understand theory and
best principles of practice through structured reflection. Bringle and Hatcher
(1996) defined service learning in the following way:
A course-based, credit-bearing educational experience in which students (a) participate in an organized service activity that meets identified community needs and (b) reflect on the service activity in such a way as to gain further understanding of the course content, a broader appreciation of the discipline, and an enhanced sense of civic responsibility. (p. 112)
Often, service learning is
identified as a process of development for creating knowledge where students
are given opportunities to transform the information they receive from their
experience and make sense of it within the theoretical framework of their
academic course material (Kuban, O’Malley, & Florea, 2014). Eyler and Giles (1999) noted that service
learning is an evolving form of pedagogy connected back to John Dewey’s
(1998/1933, 1938) calls for direct experience in the field that cultivates
well-rounded citizens.
The body of literature exploring benefits of service
learning to students, faculty, and communities is well-documented across
disciplines, including public relations pedagogy. Service learning became a
broadly accepted part of public relations education in the 1990s
(Bourland-Davis & Fall, 1997; Daugherty, 2003). Most commonly, service
learning is used in campaign or capstone courses (Aldoory & Wrigley, 1999;
Allison, 2008; Kinnick, 1999; Rogers & Andrews, 2015; Werder & Strand,
2011), and typically includes a client component (Benigni, Cheng, &
Cameron, 2004).
Given public relations’ connection to business, particularly as it relates to corporate communications and community relations in this case (Cutlip, Center, & Broom, 2006), the potential to execute service-learning projects associated with economic development initiatives is viable. Moreover, there is room for exploration in scholarship on the impact of service learning in public relations.
Value of Service Learning to Public Relations Faculty and
Students
The public relations literature offers insight to the
perceived benefits of service learning among students. Wandel (2005) found that
84% of students surveyed reported a strong preference for service-learning courses to traditional lecture learning, and that
90% of those responding believed they had learned more from the service-learning course than alternative course designs. Civic and
social efficacy among students was also a point of emphasis. Of the students
responding, 37% of those who responded planned to continue their service work
beyond the class project. Bollinger (2004) identified increased student
understanding and successful application of principles in group,
organizational, and interpersonal communication, as well as improved public
speaking acumen with the use of service-learning course components. Wilson
(2012) found value in service learning for public relations students’
critical-thinking and problem-solving skills. The most significant impact came
in students’ increased ability to identify new information needed for creative
thinking to support problem-solving. She notes creative thinking and problem
solving are of particular value to those interested in entering a dynamic,
challenging field like public relations.
Numerous researchers indicate the benefits of service
learning. Allison (2008) found common themes around the value of service
learning, including motivation for better performance, critical thinking
improvement, and exposure to the value of civic engagement. Toncar, Reid,
Burns, Anderson, and Nguyen (2006) identified perceived benefit for students’
practical skills, interpersonal skills, sense of personal responsibility, and
citizenship. Witmer, Silverman, and Gashen (2009) cited several benefits to
public relations students, including application of theory and principles of
best practice to real-world settings, teamwork experience for students,
opportunities for client interaction, and the ability to enhance civic
responsibility.
Public relations literature on service learning also
explores holistic assessment of student learning. Werder and Strand (2011)
developed and tested a model for assessing student achievement across multiple
dimensions, including practical skills, interpersonal skills, personal
responsibility, and citizenship. The model also included discipline-specific
technical, creative, and research skills. Skills found of greatest value to
students in this study included creative expression, design, writing/editing,
strategic planning, group-work dynamics,
client relations, and both quantitative and qualitative research. These skills
proved key in evaluating quality of student performance and project output.
Muturi et al. (2013) found that public relations students reported a high level of motivation from service-learning projects, viewing them as an opportunity to learn about the real world. The authors identified a key motivating factor for students to engage in service learning could be the “desire to move away from hypothetical classroom situations and into a real-world setting as the site for education” (Muturi et al., 2013, p. 400).
Research shows the service-learning experience is rewarding for faculty members as well. The public relations literature offers a body of evidence supporting the benefits of service learning to the faculty who adopt it, particularly in the areas of the pedagogical approach involved in service learning (Bollinger, 2004), a demonstration of faculty service on the tenure track (Fall & Bourland-Davis, 2004), and a more-engaged classroom (Rentner, 2011; Wandel, 2005). With benefits to public relations students and faculty discussed, the author will now address challenges and limitations of service-learning pedagogy.
Challenges and Limitations of Service Learning
Scholarship in public relations pedagogy does identify
limitations in service learning and suggests some practical considerations
before adoption of the practice in the classroom. Aldoory and Wrigley (1999)
raised concerns about discrepancies between client-partner expectations and students’ ability to deliver a
finished product that meets client-partner
needs. Rogers and Andrews (2015) identified a lack of scholarship on the
communication needs of local nonprofits and what they believe constitutes ideal
service-learning relationships. Through focus group interviews, the authors
confirmed public relations faculty assumptions that partners need a stronger
education in the practice of public relations and the public relations process.
It is clear that public relations educators need to establish a role in
educating nonprofit partners about the discipline in order to manage client
expectations of student groups. Witmer et al. (2009) found that instructors
perceived a failure of university administrators to manage perceived risks of
both students and community organizations that comprise a client partnership.
Among the challenges noted with clients were unpredictability, occasional
unprofessionalism, a vast time commitment, and the nebulous role
service-learning projects might play in the tenure and promotion process.
Witmer et al. (2009) noted that the findings raised more questions than were
answered.
Emergent strategic communication scholarship identified some students’ concerns with service-learning course projects, particularly in the area of senior capstone courses. Fraustino et al. (2019) identified several student concerns about time management, instructor and client expectations of student travel to communities, unrealistic instructor expectations of students, and a shaky sense of self-efficacy with the project. In reflection on the class experience, immediate perceived student concerns about time commitments were mitigated by how personally rewarding they found the class project experience. A consistent comment from students, however, was the potential for the capstone course project to dominate their focus and attention to the detriment of other courses. This finding drew parallels with Witmer et al.’s (2009) concerns about the potential negative impact of wide institutionalization of service learning. Another key finding was student fears about the “parachute effect,” where the class dropped in on the communities and worked toward providing assistance and recommendations; however, there was no guarantee that the communities would keep the work going over the long term on the heels of a short-term engagement with the class.
Fraustino et al. (2019) cited the need for managing
expectations, the need for being mindful of the potential of service at the
expense of learning, and the need for community assessment going into the
partnership. The authors expressed concern about the viability of
service-learning impact on communities in single capstone projects, noting that
the only means of managing the potential for a parachute effect was for the
client or professor to see the preliminary work of students to its conclusion.
The authors noted that many of the benefits of service learning stand but that
scholarship should address concerns and how to limit concerns through
performing stewardship (Waters, 2009) and closing the gap between partner
expectations and student output (Rogers & Andrews, 2015). The focus will
now shift to a discussion about the potential impact of service learning on
economic development.
Service Learning in Economic Development and Other
Subfields
Literature on the teaching and learning of public relations
has established the benefits and challenges of service learning. Scholarship in
public relations pedagogy offers clear examples of the benefits of service
learning to corporate communication (Clark, 1999), development (Kelly, 1991;
McKinnon, Longan, & Handy, 2012), public health (Rentner, 2011), and a
variety of public sector (Rothberg, Brais, & Freitag, 2016) and charitable
nonprofit programs (Bollinger, 2004). These examples establish the practical
benefits to communities collaborating with university programs that employ
service learning. Public relations literature focusing on economic development
is still in its infancy.
Fraustino et al. (2019) analyzed a service-learning project that tested a place-based branding model for promoting economic development in communities experiencing downturn. As part of two senior capstone projects, students engaged in research, development, and strategy designed to rebrand each community. Students acknowledged that the project would help them grow professionally, specifically on practical skills, interpersonal skills, career development, and personal responsibility. Through post-class surveys, students confirmed that many of the initially established desired skills to develop were met, including technical skills, teamwork skills, and client relations. The authors cited enhanced motivation among students to perform exceptional work, particularly on dimensions of professional development and community engagement. Students reflected on the experience and expressed that the service-learning campaign project left them with a sense of accomplishment, a valuable test of knowledge, and a resume builder. The authors also cited benefits to civic and community engagement. Scholarship in the teaching of economics, marketing, and management offers additional examples of the value of service learning and experiential learning to entrepreneurship and economic development for students, faculty, and the institution.
Historical and Economic Background on Marion
County and Pasaquan
Outside of a small town in the southeast, a visionary
artist named Eddie O. Martin was born in 1908 and returned home to care for the
property after his mother’s death in 1957. From 1957 until his death in 1986,
Martin transformed his home into a folk art center called Pasaquan (Patterson,
1987). For some in Marion County, he was a peculiar neighbor, who produced
admirable work and put unemployed or underemployed members of the community to
work on the grounds. For others, he was a threat to their way of life, rumored
to engage in drug dealing, homosexuality, and other forms of behavior outside
of the socially acceptable behavior of residents in the rural Southeast of the
1950s (Patterson, 1987). His apparent suicide in 1986 left Pasaquan largely
unattended, with the exception of a few men and women who formed the Pasaquan
Preservation Society.
Over time, Pasaquan fell into disrepair, and the Pasaquan Preservation
Society engaged in the process of seeking support to rehabilitate the property
and the artwork for the purposes of public exhibition. After years of petition,
and 28 years of relative neglect at the venue, the Kohler Foundation responded
and offered to facilitate the rehabilitation of Pasaquan in 2014. At the end of
the process, the Kohler Foundation identified a local university as the
appropriate caretakers for the future maintenance and stewardship of Pasaquan
after its rehabilitation completion in October 2016.
This opportunity brought with it challenges for the
university and work for the community to prepare for the takeover. To sustain
Pasaquan, the university needed a means to promote the venue that could capture
the interest of a global audience over time, the community needed to develop a
plan for supporting the venue and a broader appeal for travel and tourism, and
the previously split community needed to unify behind a reinvigorated visionary
art venue created by a mercurial former member of its community.
The process of working toward these goals provided students enrolled in two public relations courses and their instructor with the unique opportunity to cultivate relationships with local businesses, a city government, the state’s travel and tourism marketing team, and the university’s Pasaquan director. The experience created a means for public relations students to gain valuable experience in arts management, as well as arts and entertainment promotion.
The partnership between the venue and university came at
perhaps the most opportune time for Marion County and the neighboring small
town. The county and town have endured an economic downturn that began with the
migration away from production plants in the region and hit its lowest points
in the economic collapse of 2008. Unemployment figures at the time for Marion
County stood at 11.2% (United States Department of Labor, 2018). With a minor
rebound and the presence of a livestock processing plant, the employment numbers
rebounded to 7.0% in May 2015 (United States Department of Labor, 2018). The
town and county suffered another setback as the livestock processing plant
closed its facility that May, and unemployment rose to 9.4% within a month
(United States Department of Labor, 2018).
Seeing the potential of Pasaquan and understanding the need
for other economic opportunities, the Marion County Chamber of Commerce
approached the state’s Department of Economic Development about bringing in a
team to assess the potential for adapting the town, Marion County, and Pasaquan
into a travel and tourism economy. Over the fall semester of 2014, the state
economic development team visited all regional venues and held town halls with
citizens to gather information and to offer a set of recommendations to the
town about approaching revitalization, building mutually beneficial
partnerships, and adjusting the town mindset to art and cultural promotion. The
finished product was a 115-page report that detailed the resources available to
Marion County, effective models for a travel and tourism economy, and
community-specific recommendations for updating storefronts, sidewalks, and the
types of business and infrastructure they would need to develop as the new
economy began to grow over the next 5 to 10 years (Georgia Department of Economic Development, 2014).
One of the chief recommendations was to make full use of the new partnership
with the university and its various departments to achieve mutual benefit that
would help improve Marion County and the town’s prospects, while enhancing the
university’s town-gown profile.
Research Questions
On the basis of the aforementioned literature on service
learning and its value to the community and students, the researcher posed the
following research questions:
RQ1: What constitutes the process of developing and executing a multi-semester public relations service-learning project?
RQ2: To what extent do the community partners make use of the resources provided by students in public relations courses?
On the basis of the aforementioned literature documenting the potential benefits of service-learning projects, the researcher posed the following research questions:
RQ3: What evidence of economic impact on Marion County and Pasaquan can be identified since completion of the multi-semester public relations service-learning project?
RQ4: What benefits did the service-learning project provide for students engaged in the project?
METHOD
To answer the research questions, the researcher performed a mixed-methods case study analysis (Yin, 2014) for two reasons. First, the need to offer a clear breakdown of course development, execution, and impact required a comprehensive approach that documented each step in the process. Second, the timing of discovery of the influence and impact of students’ projects after course completion when reported by the local chamber of commerce limited the researcher to consider the project and its impact through a review of materials. To promote clarity, the discussion of methods employed is broken into two sections. Each is discussed below and will permit the reader to review the findings in a sequential flow.
Documenting Course Research, Design, Execution, and Partner
Adoption
As a first phase of the discussion, the researcher explained the project and its results. The researcher began with a discussion of the process of conducting course background research, course designs, students’ execution, and clients’ use of students’ work. The researcher explained the course research and design through the use of logged notes collected during the background research and course development phases of the course projects. The researcher also reviewed completed project work and student peer evaluations of other group members to assess the overall effectiveness of groups. This triangulation of differing forms of data will enable readers at other academic institutions to consider how they might adopt some of the more successful practices into their own programs. To explain the client-partners’ use of student materials, the researcher performed a qualitative review of all marketing materials, news content relating to the community and Pasaquan, as well as venue websites in the two years since the project’s completion. In addition, the researcher interviewed the Marion County Chamber of Commerce president to track the students’ work in both courses, as well as in the senior internship. To assess student benefit, the researcher’s assessment incorporated the content review of course project products, as well as a report on the work of a graduate who participated in the project in both courses and the senior internship. To identify the larger body of student engagement across the university, the researcher reviewed archived counts of student engagement collected by the Pasaquan’s site director, who documented the information for the purposes of fundraising efforts for Pasaquan.
Documenting Economic Impact
After the project completion with Pasaquan in fall 2016, the researcher decided to revisit the venue in fall 2017 to assess the progress of student recommendations with the Marion County Chamber of Commerce president. To perform the analysis, the researcher interviewed the chamber president for a report on community progress since the partnership’s inception in May 2014 and obtained economic data from January 2014 through January 2018 from the United States Department of Labor’s Unemployment Statistics and performed a simple comparative analysis to track the community’s progression, paying specific attention to the period from 2014 through 2018, to assess the progression of Pasaquan’s revitalization, opening, and the continued development and revitalization of local venues in Marion County and the town. The interview consisted of one 60-minute session, and consisted of open-ended questions focusing on progress in economic revitalization, the relationship of the county with Pasaquan, and how the students’ work influenced the efforts of the Chamber of Commerce as it progressed in its community revitalization efforts. The researcher performed his own transcription, and utilized Nvivo to conduct coding and thematic analysis of the interview, utilizing a grounded theory approach (Strauss & Corbin, 1990) in an effort to allow for emergent themes in the analysis. The findings report will begin with the development of the client partnership before progressing to the instructor’s course design, discussing campaign execution and assessment, reviewing of client adoption of student materials, and ending with an analysis of preliminary economic impact.
FINDINGS
Instructor Relationship Cultivation and Research
Shortly after the partnership announcement with Pasaquan in
summer 2014, the Department of Art tasked one
of its professors with the role of director of
Pasaquan. Among the first challenges he had to address was making Pasaquan
self-sustaining. To do so, he would need to cultivate revenue and donor
partnerships that could help keep the maintenance and promotion of the venue
viable. To achieve this end, he began brokering partnerships with faculty, the
community leadership, and the state travel and tourism board. In short, the
director was engaged in relationship management.
To earn the support of university faculty, the director of
Pasaquan brought university faculty out to the venue for a social event and a
tour of facilities to garner ideas for added value. Faculty in the sciences and
other social science disciplines brainstormed and contributed valuable ideas
for retreat meetings, conferences, and lab observations of the nature
surrounding the venue. The public relations professor conversely identified the
need for economic development in the community, the need to effectively brand
and promote Pasaquan, and the need to revitalize the brand for Marion County,
all while garnering the buy-in of the town.
With this in mind, the public relations professor brokered
a relationship with Pasaquan’s director and worked with him to cultivate an
active role with the Marion County Chamber of Commerce, a seat on the
university’s Pasaquan advisory committee, and a consulting partnership with the
state’s Department of Economic Development’s Travel and Tourism Promotion team.
The instructor’s participation in these roles allowed him to develop contextual
knowledge and collect information of value to course design. The role with the
chamber indeed helped the public relations professor build a contextual
knowledge of the community and its economic challenges. The seat on the
Pasaquan advisory committee helped the instructor learn about both the resource
and creative challenges the art venue had to address prior to takeover by the
university. Finally, the partnership with the state’s Department of Economic
Development opened the door for research data in travel and tourism that his
students would find invaluable as they tried to design and pitch a campaign. It
also enabled the instructor to bring the state economic development team to the
public relations classroom to present guest lectures on specific strategies and
tactics for effective travel and tourism public relations work, as well as
opening a line of dialog with the students to seek advice and input throughout
both courses.
Over the subsequent six months, the instructor made
bi-weekly trips to various functions at Pasaquan to strengthen relationships,
expand on his partnerships, and to collect data to build a strong course design
that would yield service-learning projects that could have tangible impact on
Marion County, the town, and Pasaquan. With a sense of the need for effective
partnership cultivation established, as well as the lead time for data
collection established, the article will now cover the design of the courses so
that the reader will understand how the projects, partnership, and products
were meant to advance the relationship and enhance student skill sets.
Course Designs
The instructor spread the client work across two courses: a
fall public relations campaigns course and a spring public relations management
course. Students in each of the courses and the senior internship were
instructed to use best practices in public relations through effective
application of RACE PR (Cutlip, Center, & Broom, 2006), ROPES PR (Kelly,
2001), and the four models of public relations communication (Grunig &
Hunt, 1984).
The fall campaigns course used a competitive pitch format
(Rentner, 2011) modified to an internal class model (McCollough, 2018). This
involved six student teams engaging in three separate competitions on behalf of
three separate clients. The student teams were pre-assigned to work together on
the basis of balance of public relations coursework experience, media
production coursework experience, and media writing acumen. The goal of the pre-assignment
was to maximize competitive balance, while providing students with experience
in working in a professional environment akin to those where they might be
hired. The three teams that won each of the three pitch competitions earned an
A on the course project while receiving thorough, constructive feedback. Those
that lost the pitch were subject to full evaluation by the instructor (see
Table 1 below).
Table 1
Competitive Team Assignments by Client Partner Need
Client Partner
Team 1
Team 2
Community Relations
20/20 PR
Peachbelt Grassroots PR
Community Marketing and PR
Kindred 5
Brevity.
Pasaquan Marketing and PR
Champion PR
Craft PR
*Winning Team Marked in Italics
The purpose of adopting a competitive evaluation model was
to encourage a higher quality of strategic planning and material development in
support of each team’s proposed campaign (McCollough, 2018). Even in losing a
pitch, with the exception of one team earning a poor grade due to poor
research, planning, and production, the other five teams earned a B or above on
the final course project. To assist each of the three clients in selecting a
winning pitch, the instructor brought in four public relations practitioners
from the community to offer constructive feedback on each team’s product and
pitch, as well as an informed perspective to relatively uninitiated clients.
Two four-member student teams worked with Marion County on
community relations work meant to help the community acclimate to supporting an
emerging travel and tourism economy, as well as growth in support for the
once-controversial Pasaquan. Two five-member student groups worked on travel
and tourism public relations intended to help develop a larger brand for the
county and town, support materials to use in promoting the town and region, and
a larger strategy meant to bring visitors into town and to push more capital
into the community. Their client was the director of the travel and tourism office
of the state’s Department of Economic Development. Finally, two five-member
student groups worked with Pasaquan’s director on cultivating a brand identity
consistent with the venue, developing marketing materials, and creating an
effective promotional strategy for Pasaquan.
Communication and effective client relations were an
essential aspect of course performance. Students met each of the three clients
at the outset of the project, were required to meet frequently with their
client and instructor as teams throughout the term, and were encouraged to
maintain open communication to achieve the best results. This line of
communication included encouraging students to discuss prospective plans for
pitches and execution in advance of roll-out to ensure the product was in line
with their client’s expectations and needs. The instructor also worked with
each client to bring every student to Pasaquan and the community to collect
preliminary data and to gain a more immersive perspective on the project and
each of its elements. This step helped students in providing a more
representative finished product that their client could more immediately employ
in practice.
The initial client conversations set the baseline for
student teams to identify preliminary areas of focus for research prior to
developing a strategy. The research work included interviews with the clients,
their respective staff, and local community members to better understand the
local context they needed to attend to in their work. For the students assigned
to Pasaquan and Marion County, students built upon this by reviewing current
promotion approaches of similar arts and travel and tourism venues, both
nationally and within the state. In support of student efforts, the state’s
travel and tourism office also provided materials on the larger travel and
tourism strategy to students to inform their strategy and align it with the
existing body of promotions in place. For students engaged in the community
relations effort, the professor provided supplemental reading on community
relations from Center, Jackson, Smith, and Stansberry (2014), including case
studies involving community relations strategy, to aid students in establishing
a contextual baseline for community relations work.
At the completion of the fall course, each of the winning
bids was collected and held for the spring public relations management course,
in which a team of seven students worked with the Marion County Chamber of
Commerce President as a client to adopt the best of each winning project in
executing a campaign that helped market Pasaquan, Marion County, and the
neighboring town. The reduction from three clients to one reflected an
anticipated consolidation of interaction once the preliminary work with
Pasaquan and the state’s travel and tourism office were complete. The move to
one seven-student team kept the group of students involved in the fall
campaigns course engaged with the efforts in the subsequent spring management
course, preserving institutional memory and reducing lag in cultivating
contextual knowledge. To ensure continuity in work, the instructor provided all
collected winning strategies as a resource tool to students to engage in a
preliminary review of strategy, prior to execution. This enabled students to
meet with the client and adapt the strategy to updated client needs and student
skills. The client took the community relations strategies at the end of the
fall course and the refined work in the spring management course and
implemented the finished product in the Chamber of Commerce.
While not part of the initial plan, the development and
implementation of promotional materials prompted a student from Marion County
in both courses to take on a senior internship course in Marion County’s
Chamber of Commerce where the student implemented the refined version of the
strategy with the client. The intern spent the final four months of her program
of study working closely with the Chamber of Commerce in developing a new
public relations strategy and executing on the initial stages of promoting
Pasaquan and helping to continue bringing in new businesses and infrastructure
to support the new travel and tourism economy, including grant writing to
support community revitalization initiatives to enhance the profile and
presence of the town. The following section will highlight the extent to which
the clients made use of student work in meeting local needs.
Quality of Student Products: Sometimes When You Lose, You
Win
In reviewing the projects and considering the ultimate
adoption of student materials, it was clear the client used both winning (Craft
PR) and losing teams’ (Champion PR) materials and strategies. In reviewing the
Pasaquan teams’ projects, one team offered strong graphic design and manuals
for standards and practice, prompting the Art Department to adopt many of their
designs in the logos for the venue’s marketing materials. The Art Department,
however, believed the losing team actually cultivated a much stronger
perspective on Pasaquan’s identity, the concept of visionary art, and the
perspective of potential visitors to the venue. Thus, much of the research and
messaging used in promotional literature and the venue’s website that
accompanies the logos of the winning team actually come from the losing team’s
book. This particular example demonstrates the relative strength of the work of
both student teams engaged in a direct competition and bodes well for
competitive modeling in service-learning courses (McCollough, 2018; Rentner, 2011). Both winning and losing team members were
able to use their work to strengthen their professional portfolios because the
client derived tangible value.
That said, there were elements that clearly posed a
challenge for some student groups. In one group, it was clear that the
inability to balance group dynamics and individual student egos limited their effectiveness in managing a
campaign. Student peer evaluations consistently discussed team disagreements
and criticism over team members’ inability to accept one another’s viewpoints
as part of the strategy. In another student group, inattention to the quality
of the writing and media produced led to the campaign falling short against a
better balanced campaign pitch despite superior research and strategy by the
other team. Finally, one team’s inability to communicate with the client for
the duration of the campaign left them well behind their opponent, making
winning a pitch a very difficult prospect. Even with the limitations on individual
projects, the overall quality of the products were stronger than in previous
campaigns courses and helped yield a solid campaign execution in the spring
semester.
Impact on the Community and Pasaquan
While not causal, the data point to strong indicators of
positive returns for Marion County and Pasaquan in terms of revenue,
development, and population growth. Interview data and the content review of
student materials and subsequent promotional materials and grant writing
indicate student work took on a foundational role upon which the community
built its materials and arguments for support. The Chamber of Commerce
president reported the county successfully obtained $62,000 in initial grant
support targeting economic development and travel and tourism promotion
support. The chamber president noted the state’s Department of Community
Affairs granted the funds on the basis of an updated design proposal from the
public relations management team for refinishing storefronts, streets, and the
courthouse grounds of the town square. This design proposal was based on the
recommendations of student teams in the public relations campaigns course
tasked to help the community adapt to effectively support Pasaquan’s guests.
The chamber president credited the partnership and project
success with enabling subsequent growth and project work from the county. Since
June 2016, eight new businesses have opened in Marion County, and there is an
ongoing conversation about the opening of seven additional businesses, according
to the Marion County Chamber of Commerce president. In addition to the proposed
openings, early reports indicated new buyers were developing recreational
hunting and lodging venues, as well as commercial real estate purchase
inquiries from potential commercial developers. Furthermore, the chamber was
working to encourage small business development through multiple seminars for
aspiring business owners and travel and tourism promotion seminars. Most
importantly, the unemployment numbers were down to 5.5% from the 9% after the
Tyson plant closed (United States Department of Labor, 2018).
Another solid indicator was the recent reports on sales tax
revenue. In the summer of 2016, the Chamber of Commerce president reported the
sales tax revenue had bottomed out in 2015 but has enjoyed a steady increase in
revenue each subsequent quarter. She attributes this increase in revenue to the
opening of new businesses and growing tourism numbers in the community related
to both Pasaquan and the partnership now in place with a regional tourism
program sponsored by the state’s Department of Economic Development. The
community relations and promotional strategies in use employed elements both
directly and indirectly sourced from the core materials and strategies developed,
presented, and shared by students in the public relations campaigns and
management courses. The finalized strategies and materials were implemented and
monitored by the senior public relations intern.
Another area of concern when the local community entered into the partnership was the potential for community growth, and early indicators also suggested successful community growth. At present, 34 housing permits have been approved for additional development. This number is the largest in the seven years the Building, Code, and Zoning Administrator has been in office. The president of the local Chamber of Commerce asked new residents about their reasons for joining the community, and several reasons were clear. Among the strongest reasons were the community culture, the strong school district, and the revitalization underway. Helping the effort are the relatively inexpensive property taxes and the positive reputation of the local government in Marion County.
Although the areas of macro-business development, shrinking
unemployment, and growth in residence and sales tax revenue were not targeted
areas of the class projects or points of focus for assessment of students, the
students’ work did directly support the migration to the new economic model and
the early promotion of Pasaquan, Marion County, and the small town within it,
which is prompting much of the subsequent growth. Data analysis indicates the
students’ initial work in both courses and through the internship provided
foundational material for revitalizing the community and contributed to raising
the profile of the primary engine for the community’s economic growth:
Pasaquan.
On October 22, 2016, Pasaquan opened to the public and was
transferred to the university foundation. At the opening, 2,200 people attended
the festivities from 34 states and 14 countries. In its first five weeks after
the opening, 892 visitors came to Pasaquan, averaging 179 visitors a week on a
3-day weekly schedule. Visitors since the opening have traveled in groups from
New York, Portland, Chicago, and Atlanta. Graduate students from Cornell
University, University of Wisconsin, University of Georgia, and Georgia State
University have conducted research on site, and it promises to host guest
artists and provide source material in its archives to art students for years
to come. In addition to several traveling exhibitions and a documentary on the
restoration, the efforts of public relations campaigns, public relations
management, and senior internship students helped the Department of Art solicit
more than $16,000 in fundraising in the first five weeks after the opening. All
promotional materials and the Web presence for Pasaquan were a direct result of
advanced research and content development on the part of students in the public
relations campaigns course and remain in use three years later. The
service-learning efforts impacted Marion County and Pasaquan, and they also
made an impact on university students.
Impact for the Students
The project work in Marion County and Pasaquan brought more
than 28 public relations campaign students, eight public relations management
students, and one senior intern to the region and helped them develop
industry-relevant experience and portfolio materials. Looking at the larger
collaboration, according to Pasaquan’s director, 120 students enrolled at the
university have helped to advance the work in Marion County and Pasaquan over
the last two years. The students came from the public relations and integrated
media production program in communication, art historians and studio students
in art, students gathering information through oral history collection and
archiving in history, students developing travel and tourism maps in geography,
and creative writing students in English. The venue’s plans for flexible use
promise to bring a more diverse, interdisciplinary group of students for future
class projects. The most obvious source of collaboration is within one of the
university’s colleges, which now produces several onsite exhibitions each year,
most notably a collaborative composition of an opera about the artist and
Pasaquan, first performed by faculty and students on the grounds in October
2017. In short, the project brought an intellectually diverse group of young
talent together to facilitate solutions intended to help revitalize a community
and elevate the profile of a unique cultural venue in the rural Southeast.
The direct impact of this project for public relations students continues to be improved marketability at graduation, as well as enhanced civic engagement. Mentioned earlier, the senior public relations student who took on the role of an intern at the Chamber of Commerce demonstrated the benefit of this approach to study for students. She did so largely because of her desire to gain more experience, but also because she was from the region and wanted to continue to help its growth. During the internship, she had a direct role in developing the marketing and promotion for the county and town. She also aided planning and executing the launch for Pasaquan and was the first ambassador for the new Pasaquan Welcome Center. The experiences she had in the internship made it possible for her to earn her first position as the communication director for a neighboring chamber of commerce, as well as maintaining her support role with the Marion County Chamber of Commerce two years after graduation. The intern’s experience and ultimate career path represents an ideal model for the civic and professional benefit of service and experiential learning (see Bollinger, 2004; Bringle & Hatcher, 1996; Wandel, 2005).
DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR EDUCATORS
As a single case, there are certainly conditions here that
proved beneficial to faculty, students, and the community. The shared mission
and vision for the project among faculty, students, community leaders, and
appropriate state agencies have much to say about the access, opportunity, and
outcome of the project. That said, none of this diminishes the level of commitment
and professional attitude and ability demonstrated by 37 students throughout
three public relations courses. It should also be noted that the researcher
acknowledges the comprehensive body of work from the students in strategy and
materials, while significant as source material for subsequent project work and
grant funding, do not explain the entire impact. In fact, there are multiple
factors that contributed to the ongoing economic improvement in the region over
the past three years. That said, the project demonstrates value in adopting
service learning for students, faculty, the university, and a community partner
on multiple fronts.
This study contributes to the limited body of knowledge
about the value of public relations education to economic development
(Fraustino et al., 2019). These findings also reinforce the body of literature
supporting the value of service learning, including impact on rural communities
(Frazier, Niehm, & Stoel, 2012; Miller, 1991; Tonn, Ezzell, & Ogle,
2010). This piece should be seen as a preliminary step in exploring means of
developing more sophisticated and nuanced models for assessing economic impact
in future scholarship on the subject, particularly on matters of long-term
impact and projects that extend beyond single-semester courses. The researcher
acknowledges the limitations of this assessment and analysis, particularly in
examining student perceptions, but also notes the potential for additional
scholarship that develops service-learning models devoted to economic
development projects, as well as tools specifically designed for assessing the
economic impact that faculty, students, and community partners achieve in
projects similar to this one.
Literature in service learning details the value of the
practice to individual students (Allison, 2008; Muturi et al., 2013; Rentner, 2011; Todd, 2014;
Toncar et al.,2006; Witmer et al., 2009) and educators (Fall &
Bourland-Davis, 2004; Wandel, 2005), and the larger view of the benefit to
organizations, communities, and the university’s original purpose and strategic
mission (Bringle & Hatcher, 1996; Greene, 2006). This case offers a model
for a project that helped advance the university mission by helping local
economic prospects, raising the profile of a visionary art venue and
strengthening a community’s buy-in during the process. Furthermore, it creates opportunities for
students to build portfolios that will make them marketable in the workforce.
The concerns posed about service learning as a
time-consuming and labor-intensive process (Fall & Bourland-Davis, 2004;
Fraustino et al., 2019; Wandel, 2005) certainly hold true here. The instructor
invested the better part of a year in research and relationship cultivation on
site in Marion County with community members, in meetings with faculty in other
departments, and in the development of a project design that would provide
students with the opportunity to meet community needs. The intent of this
research, however, is to illustrate the long-term value of the preparation and
effort to advancing the students, community, and the faculty member. This
project prompts further inquiry into the measurable impact of competition on
service learning (McCollough, 2018; Rentner, 2011), and further study of the
ultimate impact of the service-learning projects on Marion County, the town,
and Pasaquan. Further, the specific case offers an opportunity for educators to
further explore situations in which a losing
team’s work ultimately contributes to the
partner organizations.
Building and sustaining relationships through the two years
of development and coursework speaks to relationship nurturing, a key component
of stewardship in the ROPES PR model, which is commonly associated with
fundraising (Kelly, 2001; Waters, 2009). The strength of the students’
stewardship permitted the work to progress across three semesters. This is an
example of the value of teaching stewardship in service learning public
relations courses. It also suggests a potential alternative to leaving work
partially complete for the professor or client to see through (Fraustino et
al., 2019) and a potential approach to managing client expectations of student
output and timeline for useful strategy and materials (Rogers & Andrews,
2015). It also suggests an argument for developing a curriculum that
incrementally builds in service-learning coursework that culminates in a
capstone course structure, strengthening student aptitude with service learning
and providing sustained support for client partners.
For community leaders, academic decision-makers, and other interested parties, the study should also be an example of the potential value of integrating coursework with practical environments. For community leaders, the local university may be able to serve as an engine for growth and revitalization beyond enrolled students, faculty, and staff living in the region. Service learning offers an approach to teaching that engenders strong social and civic engagement from students that can facilitate change. For faculty members who are hesitant to engage in service learning for various reasons, time commitment among them, this offers an example of economic growth spurred in part at the foundational level by students working both in a classroom and in a real-world lab environment.
LIMITATIONS
A study of this nature has its limitations in assessing
impact. The researcher learned about the potential economic and community
impact of the collaborative partnership after the coursework began, and only started studying the impact of the project 15 months after the
completion of the senior internship. This limited the study to a case analysis
of student project work, student outputs, client responses to project outcomes,
and review of economic development markers after the coursework was complete.
Future scholarship on service-learning projects associated with economic
development would benefit from quantitative or qualitative survey analysis that
examines student perspectives, either from a follow-up survey (Werder &
Strand, 2011) or a pre-test and post-test model (Fraustino et al., 2019). This
would enrich the body of knowledge on the value of service learning in economic
development to public relations students in addition to the case analysis
presented here. Furthermore, in light of scholarship examining the challenges
of service learning for faculty and students (Fraustino et al., 2019; Witmer et
al., 2009), future studies in this area should examine the potential challenges
service learning can pose for faculty and students alike.
AREAS OF FURTHER STUDY
In considering the perspective of students, the students’ holistic experience with and impression of projects of this nature is of benefit and should be an area of analysis in looking at future service-learning projects that focus on economic development and community revitalization of this nature. This presents an opportunity to leverage prior scholarship and models related to the subject (Muturi et al., 2013; Rogers & Andrews, 2015; Werder & Strand, 2011) to get a better perspective on students’ responses to and benefit from service-learning projects focused on economic development.
Also valuable would be further assessment of economic impact that can be implemented at the outset of a public relations course. This study provides an example where the client partner indicates that the work of students across each semester developed strategy and materials that ultimately shaped and informed promotional materials for the arts venue, as well as background research and strategy that yielded grant support for economic-development projects. A more comprehensive instrument that would demonstrate economic performance at the outset and in the aftermath of the course project would offer a stronger argument that supports qualitative data akin to the findings in this case study.
Finally, another area of analysis is to explore the impact of embedding stewardship (Kelly, 1991, 2001; Waters, 2009) in the public relations curriculum to create service-learning partnerships that endure across semesters. The potential benefits for students in terms of sustained client partnerships and the long-term value to community partners demonstrated in this case suggest value in additional study to determine viability of embracing the practice in the public relations classroom.
REFERENCES
Aldoory, L., & Wrigley, B. (1999). Exploring the use of real clients in the PR campaigns course. Journalism & Mass Communication Educator, 54(4), 47–58. doi:10.1177/107769589905400405
Allison, A. W. (2008). A best practices service learning framework for the public relations campaigns course. Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, 8(3), 50–60. Retrieved from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ854861.pdf
Benigni, V., Cheng, I-H., & Cameron, G. (2004). The role of clients in public relations campaigns courses. Journalism & Mass Communication Educator, 59, 259–277. doi:10.1177/ 107769580405900305
Bollinger, L. (2004). Communicative benefits in a service
learning project: How a senior-level public relations class provided a campaign
and five-year plan for a nonprofit. Teaching
Public Relations, 63. Retrieved from https://aejmc.us/prd/wp-content/uploads/sites/23/2014/11/tpr63sp04.pdf
Bourland-Davis, P. G., &
Fall, L. (1997, August). Evaluation and
assessment of a service learning component in academia: A case study. Paper
presented at the annual conference of the Association
for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication. Chicago, IL.
Bringle, R., & Hatcher, J. A. (1996). A
service-learning curriculum for faculty. Michigan
Journal of Community Service Learning, 2, 112-122. Retrieved from http://hdl.handle.net/2027/spo.3239521.0002.111
Center, A. H., Jackson, P., Smith, S., & Stansberry, F.
R. (2014). Public relations practices:
Managerial case studies and problems (8th ed.). New York, NY: Pearson.
Cutlip, S. M., Center, A. H., & Broom, G. (2006). Effective public relations (11th ed.).
New York, NY: Pearson.
Data-On, M.C., & Al-Charaakh, A. (2013). The global
links program: Building pedagogy in social entrepreneurship for positive impact
in Iraq. Journal of Learning in Higher
Education, 9(2), 71-81. Retrieved from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1144127
Desplaces, D.E., Steinberg, M., Coleman, S., &
Kenworthy-U’Ren, A. (2006). A human capital model: Service-learning in the
micro business incubator program. Michigan
Journal of Community Service Learning, 13(1), 66-80. Retrieved from http://hdl.handle.net/2027/spo.3239521.0013.106
Dewey,
J. (1998). How we think: A
restatement of the relation of reflective thinking to the educative process. Boston,
MA: Houghton Mifflin. (Original work
published 1933).
Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York, NY:
Collier Books.
Eyler, J., & Giles, D. E. (1999). Where’s the learning in service learning? San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Fraustino, J. D., Pressgrove, G., & Colistra, R. (2019). Extending understanding of service-learning projects: Implementing place-based branding for capstone courses, Communication Teacher, 33(1), 45-62. doi: 10.1080/17404622.2017.1372609
Frazier, B.J., Niehm, L.S., & Stoel, L. (2012).
Connecting college learners with rural entrepreneurship opportunities: The
rural entrepreneurship teaching unit. Journal
of Case Studies in Education, 2, 1-20. Retrieved from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1109729
Greene, G.R. (2006). Cultivating reciprocity: The guiding
framework for Benedict College in partnership with the community to garner
economic and community growth. Journal of
Higher Education Outreach and Engagement, 11(3), 53-63. Retrieved from http://openjournals.libs.uga.edu/index.php/jheoe/article/view/155
Grunig J. E., & Grunig L. A. (2008). Excellence theory
in public relations: Past, present, and future. In A. Zerfass, B. van Ruler,
& K. Sriramesh (Eds.), Public
relations research. Wiesbaden, Germany: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
Grunig, J. E., & Hunt, T.
(1984). Managing public relations.
Austin, TX: Holt, Rinehart, & Winston.
Kelly, K. (2001). Stewardship: The fifth step in the public relations process. In R. L. Heath (Ed.), Handbook of public relations (pp. 279-289). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Kinnick, K. N. (1999). The
communication campaigns course as a model for incorporating service learning
into the curriculum. In D. Droge & B. Ortega Murphy (Eds.), Voices of strong democracy: Concepts and
models for service-learning in communication studies (pp. 155–170).
Washington, DC: American Association of Higher Education.
Kuban, A. J., O’Malley, M.
M., & Florea, L. J. (2014). Students’ knowledge and perceived confidence in
an interdisciplinary experiential learning environment. Journal of Community Engagement and Higher Education, 6(2),
30-38. Retrieved from https://discovery.indstate.edu/jcehe/index.php/joce/article/view/231/191
McKinnon, L. M., Longan, J., & Handy, B. (2012).
Service-learning for branding success: A case of student-client engagement in
Oklahoma State University’s $1 billion capital campaign. Teaching Public Relations, 84. Retrieved from https://aejmc.us/prd/wp-content/uploads/sites/23/2014/11/tpr84fall12.pdf
Miller, B. (1991). Service-learning in support of rural
community development. In A. Waterman (Ed.), Service-learning: Applications from the research (pp. 107-126).
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Muturi, N., An, S., & Mwangi, S. (2013). Students expectations and motivations for service-learning in public relations. Journalism and Mass Communication Educator,68(4), 387-408. doi: 10.1177/1077695813506992
Patterson, T. (1987). St. EOM in the Land of Pasaquan. East
Haven, CT: Inland Book Company.
Rogers, C., & Andrews, V. (2015). Nonprofits’ expectations in PR service–learning partnerships. Journalism & Mass Communication Educator, 71(1), 95–106. doi: 10.1177/1077695815584226
Rothberg, R., Brais, S. J., & Freitag, A. R. (2016).
Improving grease disposal behavior: Combining the classroom, real-world
experience and service learning in a public relations practicum. Journal of Public Relations Education, 2(2).
Retrieved from https://aejmc.us/jpre/category/jpre-issues/volume-two/
Sigmon, R. (1979). Service-learning: Three principles. Synergist, 8(1), 9–11.
Strauss, A., &
Corbin, J. M. (1990). Basics of
qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage.
Todd, V. (2014). Public relations supervisors and millennial entry-level practitioners rate entry-level job skills and professional characteristics. Public Relations Review, 40(5), 789-797. doi: 10.1016/j.pubrev.2014.05.002
Toncar, M. F., Reid, J. S., Burns, D. J., Anderson, C. E., & Nguyen, H. P. (2006). Uniform assessment of the benefits of service learning: The development, evaluation, and implementation of the SELEB scale. The Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, 14(3), 223–238. doi:10.2753/ MTP1069-6679140304
Tonn, B., Ezzell, T., &
Ogle, E. (2010). Experiential learning and sustainable economic development in
Appalachian communities: A teaching note. Journal
of Appalachian Studies, 16(1 & 2), 144-155. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/41446847
Waters, R. D. (2009). Measuring stewardship in public relations: A test exploring impact on the fundraising relationship. Public Relations Review, 35, 113-119. doi: 10.1016/j.pubrev.2009.01.012
Werder, K. P., & Strand, K. (2011). Measuring student
outcomes: An assessment of service-learning in the public relations campaigns
course. Public Relations Review, 37(5),
478-484. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2011.09.014
Wilson, B. (2012). Service learning in the public relations
classroom: An experiential approach to improving students’ critical-thinking
and problem-solving skills. Teaching
Public Relations, 83. Retrieved from https://aejmc.us/prd/wp-content/uploads/sites/23/2014/11/tpr83sp12.pdf
Witmer, D. F., Silverman, D. A., & Gaschen, D. J. (2009). Working to learn and learning to work: A profile of service-learning courses in university public relations programs. Public Relations Review, 35(2), 153–155. doi:10.1016/j.pubrev.2009.02.001
Yin, R. K. (2014). Case
study research and design methods (5th ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Author Note
The author wishes to acknowledge and thank his conference
reviewers, conference respondent, and the reviewers and editorial team. Their
thoughtful comments, suggestions, and questions about structure, focus, and
alternative literature reflect the best of an emphasis among reviewers and
respondents in the Public Relations Division of the Association for Education
in Journalism and Mass Communication to provide meaningful feedback and input
throughout the review and presentation process. Their efforts helped the author
make an award-winning paper stronger, and provided the author with some ideas
for extension of the work into future areas of scholarship.
Correspondence concerning this article should be directed to Christopher J. McCollough, Department of Communication, Columbus State University, Columbus, GA 31907. Contact: chris.mccollough@columbusstate.edu